Maruti Swift and Tata Tiago are two practical hatchbacks in India. The sporty-looking Maruti Swift was launched in 2005 and is also in its fourth generation today. The more rugged-looking Tata Tiago made its debut in early 2016 and is still in its first generation. In terms of fuel efficiency, the Swift CNG has an average on-road mileage of 24 km/kg, while the Tiago CNG averages at 22.5 km/kg.
The Maruti Swift and Tata Tiago use a 1.2L naturally aspirated petrol engine and a petrol+CNG engine. They also have similar transmissions of 5-speed manual and 5-speed AMT. These hatchbacks have several similarities, and their comparison will be interesting. In this blog, we will see their mileage, fuel costs and other specifications to know how they perform on the road.
Table of Contents
Maruti Swift vs Tata Tiago Specifications
Check the table below to see the key specifications of the Maruti Swift and Tata Tiago and see where the similarities and differences are.
| Specification | Maruti Swift | Tata Tiago |
| Engine | 1.2L Z-Series Petrol1.2L Z-Series Petrol+CNG | 1.2L NA Petrol1.2L Petrol+CNG |
| Displacement | 1197 cc | 1199 cc |
| Power | Petrol: 81.58PSCNG: 69.75PS | Petrol: 86PSCNG: 75.5PS |
| Torque | Petrol: 111.7 NmCNG: 101.8 Nm | Petrol: 113 NmCNG: 96.5 Nm |
| Transmission | 5-Speed Manual5-Speed AMT | 5-Speed Manual5-Speed AMT |
| Drive layout | Front Wheel Drive | Front Wheel Drive |
| Kerb weight | Petrol: 920-925 KgCNG: 990 Kg | Petrol: 935-990 KgCNG: 1030-1122 Kg |
| Fuel tank capacity | Petrol: 37 litresCNG: 55 litres | Petrol: 35 litresCNG: 60 litres |
The Maruti Swift and Tata Tiago have many similar specifications even though they come from different brands. Their engine capacity, transmission types, and the lack of a diesel engine are all the same. The major differences are seen in the kerb weight, fuel tank capacity, power and torque. The Swift has a higher petrol tank capacity, while the Tiago has a larger capacity for CNG. Tiago has a higher kerb weight than the Swift and has more power and torque as well. Whether the power and torque help it perform better to get higher mileage will be seen from the ARAI and real-world mileage comparisons.
Maruti Swift vs Tata Tiago: ARAI Mileage Figures
The ARAI mileage figures are the results of tests conducted by the Automotive Research Association of India. These tests under controlled conditions and fixed speed will reveal the maximum possible mileage by these hatchbacks. But these are simply tentative figures and are not usually seen with their real-world performance.
| Engine & Transmission | Fuel Type | Maruti Swift – ARAI Mileage (km/l) | Tata Tiago- ARAI Mileage (km/l) |
| 1.2L Z-Series MT | Petrol | 24.80 Km/l | NA |
| 1.2L Z-Series AMT | Petrol | 25.75 Km/l | NA |
| 1.2L Z-Series | Petrol+CNG | 32.85 Km/Kg | NA |
| 1.2L NA MT | Petrol | NA | 19.01 Km/l |
| 1.2L NA AMT | Petrol | NA | 20.09 Km/l |
| 1.2L iCNG MT | Petrol+CNG | NA | 26.49 Km/Kg |
| 1.2L iCNG AMT | Petrol+CNG | NA | 28.06 Km/Kg |
The ARAI tests show that the mileage of Maruti Swift is far superior to the Tata Tiago on all their powertrains. The Swift CNG has the highest mileage, followed by petrol AMT and petrol manual. For the Tata Tiago, the CNG AMT is the best performer, followed by the CNG manual variant. Similarly, its AMT variant performs better than the manual version for the petrol variants as well. Let’s see how much mileage these hatchbacks can achieve in the real world.
Maruti Swift vs Tata Tiago: Real World Fuel-Efficiency
The real-world fuel efficiency matters more than the ARAI claims. The actual on-road mileage of Maruti Swift and Tata Tiago is provided in the table below.
| Maruti Swift (Petrol) | Tata Tiago (Petrol) | Maruti Swift (CNG) | Tata Tiago (CNG) | |
| City | 12-16 Km/l | 12-15 Km/l | 21-24 Km/Kg | 17-20 Km/Kg |
| Highway | 18-22 Km/l | 16-19 Km/l | 26-35 Km/Kg | 24-28 Km/Kg |
| Average | 17 Km/l | 15.5 Km/l | 24 Km/Kg | 22.5 Km/Kg |
| Tank range | 600-700 Km | 455-595 Km | 850- 900 Km | 750-850 Km |
The CNG versions of Swift and Tiago continue their dominance in the real world as well. The Swift CNG sustains its ARAI claims with near-perfect mileage on the highways, but it mainly depends on the driving style and other factors. The Tiago CNG almost achieves its claims on the highways. However, both hatchbacks show lower mileage on the city roads. Their petrol variants have a much lower mileage than the claimed figures. In the petrol variants also, the Swift shows a better average.
Also Read: Tata Tiago Mileage Comparison: Petrol vs CNG vs Electric
Maruti Swift vs Tata Tiago: Fuel Cost Comparison
A car is considered highly fuel efficient when it delivers higher mileage and has a lower fuel cost. The fuel cost of the Maruti Swift and Tata Tiago are given below. For convenience, the data is split into petrol and CNG. The average distance travelled and prices of petrol and CNG are considered at 1500 Km, Rs. 111 and Rs. 85, respectively.
| Maruti Swift (Petrol) | Tata Tiago (Petrol) | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Running | 1500 km | 1500 km |
| Monthly Fuel Use | 90L | 96L |
| Average Monthly Fuel Cost | ₹ 9990 | ₹ 10.656 |
| Average Yearly Fuel Cost | ₹ 1.19 lakhs | ₹ 1.27 lakhs |
| 5-Year Fuel Cost | ₹5.99 lakhs | ₹6.39 lakhs |
The difference in mileage saves around Rs.40k over 5 years for the Maruti Swift. There is no major difference in the fuel cost of the Swift and Tiago on a monthly basis. The Yearly savings of the Swift are just noticeable.
| Maruti Swift (CNG) | Tata Tiago (CNG) | |
|---|---|---|
| Monthly Running | 1500 km | 1500 km |
| Monthly Fuel Use | 64 Kg | 66 Kg |
| Average Monthly Fuel Cost | ₹ 5440 | ₹ 5610 |
| Average Yearly Fuel Cost | ₹ 65,280 | ₹ 67,320 |
| 5-Year Fuel Cost | ₹3.26 lakhs | ₹3.36 lakhs |
At the same time, the savings on fuel cost by the CNG variant of both hatchbacks are more profound. The CNG variant can save anywhere between Rs. 2.4 lakhs to 3 lakhs. If you choose the Maruti Swift CNG, you can save the most on fuel cost.
Also Read: Maruti Swift Mileage Comparison: Petrol vs CNG
Maruti Swift vs Tata Tiago Price
Here is a glance at the ex-showroom prices of Maruti Swift and Tata Tiago.
| Model | Variant (Base to Top) | Price (Ex-Showroom) |
| Maruti Swift | LXi to ZXi | ₹ 5.79 lakhs to 8.84 lakhs |
| Tata Tiago | Smart to Creative + | ₹ 4.70 lakhs to 8.55 lakhs |
The Tata Tiago has a lower ex-showroom price than the Swift variants. However, the Swift can help you save more on running costs.
Summary
In comparison with the Tata Tiago, the Maruti Swift is the winner. It offers better mileage in the real world and can help you save more on fuel costs. Its CNG variant offers better fuel efficiency than its petrol variant. The Tiago CNG also showcases competent mileage on both highways and city roads. The Tata Tiago is more suitable for budget-buyers. But the Maruti Swift has better mileage, lower fuel cost, higher resale value, and is easier to maintain.
Related Reads:
Maruti Swift vs Hyundai Grand i10 Nios: Real-World Mileage Comparison
Hyundai Grand i10 Nios vs Tata Tiago Real World Mileage Comparison
Honda City vs Volkswagen Virtus Real World Mileage Comparison
FAQs About Maruti Swift vs Tata Tiago Mileage
Does the Tiago’s heavier build affect its mileage?
Yes, Tiago’s weight does affect the fuel efficiency. It is more visible in city traffic where there is constant braking and acceleration. During these times, the engine works harder, and therefore the mileage is reduced. However, the driving style, road conditions, and general traffic also play their role in the mileage.
How do Swift and Tiago perform on the city roads?
Swift has better performance than the Tiago on urban roads. In the city, the Maruti Swift feels lighter and is more convenient to drive. The Tiago is heavier, and it takes some effort to navigate through the traffic. Moreover, the Swift has better mileage on city roads than the Tiago.
Which hatchback offers a more relaxed drive on the highways, Maruti Swift or Tata Tiago?
For a relaxed drive on the highways, the Tata Tiago is more suitable. Although the Swift is also convenient for highways, the Tiago offers better stability and stays solid.
Which car can save better on fuel cost when driving in the city?
The Swift is the winner in terms of mileage regardless of where you drive. It is a better choice than the Tiago as it is highly fuel efficient across its powertrains. Its lighter body shows better fuel economy and is more convenient for urban driving.
Which car is the better choice keeping in mind the rising fuel charges?
If the rising fuel charges are your main concern, then the Maruti Swift is the best choice. While its petrol variants show higher mileage than the Tiago and can help you save big on fuel cost, its CNG variant is the star of the show with the best mileage and higher savings. When compared to the petrol variant, it can save more than Rs. 2 lakhs. At the same time, the Tiago CNG is also a better option than the petrol variant of the Swift.
