Kia Carens is a Multi-Purpose Vehicle (MPV) that is known for its advanced features and cabin comfort. Its 1.5-Litre Naturally Aspirated (NA) petrol engine is paired with a 6-speed manual transmission, whereas its 1.5-litre turbo petrol engine is paired with a 6-speed iMT or 7-speed dual-clutch transmission (DCT) automatic transmission. The CNG variants offer only a manual transmission, whereas the diesel variants are paired with either a 6-speed manual or a 6-speed automatic transmission.
Toyota Innova Hycross is also an MPV that comes with either a 7-seater or 8-seater configuration. It offers a strong hybrid variant and a 2.0-litre NA petrol engine for those who are not interested in the hybrid models. Both these models are available with automatic transmission options only. In this blog, we will compare Kia Carens vs Toyota Innova Hycross on the basis of their real-world mileage figures.
Kia Carens vs Toyota Innova Hycross: Key Specifications
Certain specifications such as kerb weight or power generated by the engine can also influence the mileage of cars. So, before understanding the difference between the mileage of these cars, let’s take a look at their specifications. The table below reflects the key specifications of the Kia Carens and Toyota Innova Hycross:
| Specification | Kia Carens | Toyota Innova Hycross |
| Engine | 1.5-Litre Naturally Aspirated (NA) Petrol 1.5-Litre TGDi Turbo-Petrol 1.5-Litre TGDi Turbo-Petrol + CNG 1.5-Litre CRDi VGT Diesel | 2.0-litre NA Petrol 2.0-litre Strong Hybrid Petrol Engine |
| Displacement | Petrol/CNG: 1497 cc Diesel: 1493 cc | 1987 cc |
| Power | Petrol: 115 PS Turbo Petrol: 160 PS Diesel: 116 PS | Petrol: 174 PS Strong Hybrid: 126 kW |
| Torque | Petrol: 144 Nm Turbo Petrol: 253 Nm Diesel: 250 Nm | Petrol: 209 Nm Strong Hybrid: 188 Nm |
| Transmission | 6-speed Manual, 6-speed iMT6-speed Automatic, 7-speed DCT | Petrol: CVT Strong Hybrid: e-Drive Automatic |
| Drive layout | Front Wheel Drive (FWD) | Front Wheel Drive (FWD) |
| Kerb weight | 1300 to 1530 kg depending upon the variant | Petrol: 1730 kg Strong Hybrid: 1916 kg |
| Fuel tank capacity | 45 litres | 52 litres |
The NA petrol variants of Innova Hycross generate more power and torque than the NA petrol variants of Kia Carens. However, the turbo petrol variants of Kia Carens are much ahead in terms of power and torque generation if we compare them with the strong hybrid models of Hycross. The kerb weight of Hycross is also on the higher side. These things might affect the mileage of these cars but you must also note that the engines of Innova Hycross are better tuned for fuel-efficiency that the engines of Carens.
Also Explore: Kia Carens Image Gallery: Interior and Exterior
Kia Carens vs Toyota Innova Hycross: ARAI Claimed Mileage Figures
ARAI tests the mileage of cars individually to determine their optimal mileage figures. As these tests are performed in ideal conditions with minimum load, the cars deliver a much higher mileage during the ARAI tests. However, it becomes important to check the claimed mileage of the cars because it gives the car buyers an idea of the mileage they can expect in real-world conditions. The below table provides key insights regarding the claimed mileage figures of Kia Carens vs Toyota Innova Hycross:
| Engine & Transmission | Fuel Type | Kia Carens – ARAI Mileage (km/l) | Toyota Innova Hycross – ARAI Mileage (km/l) |
| 1.5-litre NA Petrol + 6-Speed MT | NA Petrol | 15.7 km/l | – |
| 1.5-litre Turbo Petrol + 6-Speed iMT | Turbo Petrol | 15.95 km/l | – |
| 1.5-litre Turbo Petrol + 7-Speed DCT | Turbo Petrol | 16.66 km/l | – |
| 1.5-Litre CRDi VGT Diesel – MT | Diesel | 21.3 km/l | – |
| 1.5-Litre CRDi VGT Diesel – AT | Diesel | 18.4 km/l | – |
| 1.5-litre petrol + CNG – Manual | CNG | 17.20 km/l | – |
| 2.0-litre 2.0-litre NA Petrol – CVT | Petrol | – | 16.13 km/l |
| 2.0-litre Strong Hybrid – eDrive | Strong Hybrid | – | 23.24 km/l |
As Kia Carens offers multiple engine and transmission options, you find a wide range of mileage across its powertrains. Yet, when we compare its NA petrol models with the NA petrol variant of Hycross, Hycross claims a slightly better mileage. Also, the strong hybrid variants of Innova Hycross are far ahead than Kia Carens when it comes to ARAI-certified mileage.
The diesel variants of Carens come 2nd when we compare the overall powertrains of both these cars. However, most of these comparisons are futile except the comparison of NA petrol models as the other powertrains offered by these cars are entirely different. Yet, if we have to name one, we will consider Hycross as the overall winner due to its higher claimed mileage with the strong hybrid variants and better mileage claimed with the NA petrol models.
Kia Carens proves to be more versatile with its engine and transmission configurations but Innova Hycross leads the race with the highest mileage delivered by its strong hybrid powertrain.
Kia Carens vs Toyota Innova Hycross: Real World Mileage
The real world mileage of cars varies because of the varying road conditions and unique driving styles of car owners. Factors such as the design of the car, drag co-efficient, and engine tuning also affect the real-world mileage of cars. So, let’s compare Carens and Innova Hycross on the basis of their real-world mileage now. The table below gives details regarding the exact real-world mileage figures of both these cars across the powertrains:
| Kia Carens (1.5-litre NA Petrol) | Toyota Innova Hycross (2.0-litre NA Petrol) | |
| City | 11 km/l | 8 to 11 km/l |
| Highway | 13 km/l | 13 to 16 km/l |
| Average | 12 km /l | 10.5 to 13.5 km /l |
| Tank range | 540 km | 600 km |
| Kia Carens (1.5-litre Turbo Petrol) | Toyota Innova Hycross (2.0-litre Strong Hybrid) | |
| City | iMT: 10.0 km/l DCT: 11 km/l | e-CVT: 18.0 – 21.0 km/l |
| Highway | iMT: 16.4 km/l DCT: 14.2 km/l | e-CVT: 18.5 – 21.0 km/l |
| Average | iMT: 13.0 km/l DCT: 12.0 km/l | e-CVT: 19.5 km/l |
| Tank range | ~580 km | ~1,020 km |
| Kia Carens (1.5-litre Diesel) | Toyota Innova Hycross (Diesel is Not Available) | |
| City | MT: 13.0 – 15.0 km/l AT: 11.0 – 13.0 km/l | – |
| Highway | MT: 18.0 – 20.0 km/l AT: 16.0 – 18.0 km/l | – |
| Average | MT: 16.0 km/l AT: 14.5 km/l | – |
| Tank range | ~720 km | – |
| Kia Carens (1.5-litre CNG) | Toyota Innova Hycross (CNG Not Available) | |
| City | 16.0 – 18.0 km/kg | – |
| Highway | 22.0 – 24.0 km/kg | – |
| Average | 20.0 km/kg | – |
| Tank range | ~170 – 180 km | – |
Comparing the real-world mileage of Innova Hycross and Kia Carens is futile due to their entirely different powertrains. The real-world mileage of NA petrol variants of Innova Hycross is on the higher side as compared to the NA petrol variants of Carens. The turbo petrol variants of Carens deliver a much lower mileage in the real world as compared to the strong hybrid variants of Hycross.
When it comes to real-world range, the diesel variants of Carens come quite close to the strong hybrid variants of Innova Hycross. So, we can say that Innova Hycross offers better real-world mileage than Kia Carens but when it comes to offering a diverse range in mileage, Kia Carens seems to be the better option.
Innova Hycross offers better real-world mileage than Kia Carens but when it comes to versatility, Kia Carens is the winner since it also offers diesel and CNG powertrains.
Also Explore: Toyota Innova Hycross Image Gallery: Interior, Exterior
Kia Carens vs Toyota Innova Hycross: Periodic Fuel Cost Comparison
Comparing the fuel costs of two cars is natural while comparing their mileage. So, after checking the differences between their real-world mileage, let’s compare these cars on the basis of their periodic fuel costs. For a fair comparison, we have considered that both these cars run 1500 km every month.
The latest petrol (Rs. 111.18), diesel (Rs. 97.50), and CNG (Rs. 88 per kg) are taken for calculating the monthly, annual, and 5-yearly fuel costs of Kia Carens and Toyota Innova Hycross models. The below table contains the fuel-cost comparison across the powertrains of both these cars:
| Kia Carens NA Petrol | Kia Carens Turbo Petrol | Toyota Innova Hycross NA Petrol | Toyota Innova Hycross Strong Hybrid | |
| Monthly Running | 1,500 km | 1,500 km | 1,500 km | 1,500 km |
| Monthly Fuel Use | 125 litres | 115 litres | 125 litres | 87 litres |
| Average Monthly Fuel Cost | ₹ 13,897 | ₹ 12,785 | ₹ 13,897 | ₹ 9673 |
| Average Yearly Fuel Cost | ₹1.66 lakh | ₹ 1.53 lakh | ₹1.66 lakh | ₹ 1.16 lakh |
| 5-Year Fuel Cost | ₹ 8.33 lakh | ₹ 7.67 lakh | ₹ 8.33 lakh | ₹ 5.8 lakh |
| Kia Carens CNG | Innova Hycross CNG – Not Available | Kia Carens Diesel | Toyota Innova Hycross Diesel – Not Available | |
| Monthly Running | 1,500 km | – | 1,500 km | – |
| Monthly Fuel Use | 81 litres | – | 83 litres | – |
| Average Monthly Fuel Cost | ₹ 7128 | – | ₹ 8092 | – |
| Average Yearly Fuel Cost | ₹ 85,536 | – | ₹ 97,104 lakh | – |
| 5-Year Fuel Cost | ₹ 4.27 lakh | – | ₹ 4.85 lakh | – |
Surprisingly, the periodic fuel costs associated with the NA petrol variants of Carens is exactly the same as Innova Hycross’s NA petrol fuel costs. This is because we have considered the average mileage delivered by Carens NA petrol models while calculating the periodic fuel costs. The turbo petrol variants of Carens are far more expensive than the strong hybrid variants of Innova Hycross when we compare their fuel costs.
The real-world mileage of the diesel and CNG variants of Kia Carens are a lot lesser than the real-world mileage of strong hybrid variants of Innova Hycross. However, as diesel and CNG are less expensive fuels, the periodic fuel costs associated with diesel and CNG variants of Kia Carens are lesser than the periodic fuel costs associated with the strong hybrid variants of Hycross. So, car buyers can remember these statistics rather than opting for a car only because of its strong hybrid powertrain.
Kia Carens outperforms Innova Hycross with the cheap running costs associated with its diesel and CNG variants. However, for car buyers who only want a petrol car, the strong hybrid or NA variants of Hycross are still the preferable options.
Kia Carens vs Toyota Innova Hycross: Price Comparison
Pricing is a crucial factor while comparing two cars. So, let’s compare the pricing difference in the base and top models of Kia Carens and Toyota Innova Hycross now:
| Model | Variant (Base to Top) | Price (Ex-Showroom) |
| Toyota Innova Hycross | G Fleet 7STR to ZX(O) Hybrid | ₹ 18.70 lakh to ₹ 32.95 lakh |
| Kia Carens | Base to top model | ₹11.12 lakh to ₹12.98 lakh |
Kia Carens is quite affordable in terms of pricing if we compare the ex-showroom price of its base and top models with the base and top model pricing of Toyota Innova Hycross.
Also Read: Kia Carens Alternatives: Competitors of Kia Carens
Summary
Both Kia Carens and Toyota Innova Hycross come with different powertrain combinations. So, instead of comparing them directly, it is better to find which variant is suitable according to your driving preferences. For highway driving and swift overtakes, we recommend the diesel variants of Kia Carens. For city driving, you can opt for the NA petrol or strong hybrid variants of Toyota Innova Hycross.
Related Blogs:
Kia Carens vs Maruti Ertiga Real World Mileage Comparison
Kia Carens vs Toyota Innova Crysta Real-World Mileage Comparison
Maruti Ertiga Vs Toyota Innova Hycross: Real World Mileage Comparison
FAQs about Kia Carens and Toyota Innova Hycross Mileage
Q. Which car delivers better mileage in the city: Kia Carens or Toyota Innova Hycross?
The NA petrol variants of Toyota Innova offer slightly better mileage in the city as compared to the NA petrol variants of Kia Carens. However, if you are ok with a diesel or CNG variant, you can go for the diesel or CNG models of Carens due to their low running costs.
Q. Which car is more suitable for driving in the ghats: Kia Carens or Toyota Innova Hycross?
The diesel variants of Kia Carens will be a much better option than the Innova Hycross because of their low-end torque and strong mid-range pull.
Q. Which car is more suitable for highway driving: Innova Hycross strong hybrid or Kia Carens turbo petrol?
Both are equally good but if you want to experience more power and a thrilling driving experience, the turbo petrol models of Kia Carens could prove to be a better option.
Q. How much mileage do the NA petrol models of Kia Carens deliver in the city?
The NA petrol models of Kia Carens deliver a mileage of up to 11 km/l in the city.
Q. How much mileage do the strong hybrid models of Toyota Innova Hycross deliver on the highway?
The strong hybrid models of Toyota Innova Hycross deliver a mileage of up to 22 km/l on the highway.
