In India, the Mahindra Scorpio N, Force Gurkha 5 Door, and Maruti Suzuki Jimny all provide solid competition to the Mahindra Thar Roxx. The Scorpio has more seating capacity and aspects of family usability; the Gurkha focuses more on true off-road capabilities, while the Jimny offers a genuine four-wheel drive at a lower price point.
The Thar Roxx itself blends lifestyle-SUV appeal with the comfort and features of a modern family SUV. It comes with petrol and diesel engines, manual and automatic gearboxes, rear-wheel drive and diesel 4WD options, a feature-rich cabin and a five-star Bharat NCAP safety rating. That makes these three rivals worth considering depending on whether your priority is space, off-road capability, mileage, or price.
Quick Summary
- The Mahindra Scorpio N is the best alternative for buyers who want six- or seven-seat practicality with powerful engines and available 4WD.
- The Force Gurkha 5 Door suits buyers who prioritise hardcore off-road hardware, including front and rear differential locks.
- The Maruti Suzuki Jimny is the most affordable 4WD alternative and is easier to use in cities and narrow trails.
- The Mahindra Thar Roxx is priced from around ₹12.52 lakh to ₹23.52 lakh ex-showroom.
- It offers a 2.0-litre turbo-petrol and a 2.2-litre diesel engine with manual and automatic gearbox options.
- The Scorpio N offers more seats, the Gurkha offers standard 4WD, and the Jimny offers claimed mileage of up to 16.94 km/l.
- Buyers wanting the best balance of performance, premium features, safety, and off-road ability may still prefer the Thar Roxx.
Table of Contents
Price and Mileage Comparison with Mahindra Thar Roxx
The Thar Roxx has quite a varied pricing range, given the availability of a number of petrol, diesel, manual, automatic, RWD features and 4WD options. The Mahindra Scorpio N competes with it on many fronts; the Gurkha occupies a middle ground in the price range, and the Jimny is positioned at the lower side of the spectrum.
| Car | Ex-showroom Price Range | Fuel Type | Claimed Mileage |
| Mahindra Thar Roxx | ₹12.52 – ₹23.52 lakh | Petrol, Diesel | Petrol: around 12.4 km/l; Diesel: around 15.2 km/l |
| Mahindra Scorpio N | ₹13.69 – ₹25.49 lakh | Petrol, Diesel | Petrol: around 12.1 km/l; Diesel: up to around 15.9 km/l |
| Force Gurkha 5 Door | Around ₹17.63 lakh | Diesel | Around 15 km/l |
| Maruti Suzuki Jimny | ₹12.54 – ₹14.67 lakh | Petrol | 16.94 km/l MT; 16.39 km/l AT |
Top Alternatives to Mahindra Thar Roxx in India
Mahindra Scorpio N
Mahindra Scorpio N has emerged as the most comparable competitor to the Thar Roxx. It is a body-on-frame SUV with powerful engine options such as petrol and diesel engines, along with 4WD capabilities in select diesel versions. However, the size of the Scorpio N is bigger, with dimensions of approximately 4,662 mm and 1,917 mm in length and width,h respectively, in six- and seven-seater configurations.
Its 2.0-litre turbo-petrol produces around 203 PS, while the 2.2-litre diesel is offered in different states of tune, with higher variants producing around 175 PS. Six-speed manual and six-speed torque-converter automatic gearboxes are available. Selected diesel variants also get 4WD, making the Scorpio N suitable for buyers who still want genuine off-road capability.
Why it is better than Mahindra Thar Roxx
The obvious benefit of the Scorpio N is its usefulness for families. The Thar Roxx has a capacity of five passengers, while the Scorpio N can be equipped with seats for up to six or seven passengers. In terms of its design, the Scorpio N also benefits from the traditional SUV layout with three rows of seating.
Higher variants add large digital displays, ventilated seats, premium audio, surround-view cameras, connected-car features, and Level 2 ADAS. The Thar Roxx feels more lifestyle-oriented, but the Scorpio N makes more sense for buyers who want rugged Mahindra character with greater passenger capacity.
Price Comparison: Mahindra Scorpio N vs. Mahindra Thar Roxx
With the price of the Scorpio N being higher than that of the Thar Roxx, overall the pricing of both vehicles is similar, and information on equivalent diesel and 4WD models can be consulted for price comparisons when making the choice of buying.
| Variant | Mahindra Scorpio N | Mahindra Thar Roxx |
| Base-variant | Around ₹13.69 lakh | Around ₹12.52 lakh |
| Mid-variant | Around ₹17 – ₹19 lakh | Around ₹16 – ₹19 lakh |
| Top-variant | Up to ₹25.49 lakh | Up to ₹23.52 lakh |
Also Read: Mahindra Scorpio N Variants Guide: Choose the Best Variant
Force Gurkha 5 Door
The Force Gurkha 5 Door serves as an improved means of traffic passage. It employs a fixed-frame design and a 2.6-litre diesel motor that develops around 140 hp and 320 Nm of torque, along with the use of a helpful 5-speed manual transmission.
Four-wheel drive is standard, along with low-range gearing, mechanically locking front and rear differentials, approximately 233 mm of ground clearance, and water-wading ability of up to 700 mm. This makes the Gurkha particularly appealing to buyers who spend more time tackling difficult terrain.
Why it is better than Mahindra Thar Roxx
When it comes to true off-road performance, the Gurkha’s technical capabilities particularly shine through. Its locking differentials allow the vehicle to regain some traction when any of its wheels lose grip, and it can wade in water up to 700 mm in depth, which is better than the Thar Roxx’s approximate performance of 650 mm.
The Gurkha 5 Door also offers seven-seat capacity, giving it an advantage over the five-seat Roxx. However, it lacks the Thar Roxx’s petrol engine, automatic gearbox, premium audio, panoramic sunroof, and Level 2 ADAS. It therefore suits buyers who value rugged capability more than comfort and technology.
Price Comparison: Force Gurkha 5 Door vs. Mahindra Thar Roxx
The Gurkha 5 Door is sold in one main variant instead of being part of a rich variant range, which again places it at a mid-level in the Thar Roxx hierarchy.
| Variant | Force Gurkha 5 Door | Mahindra Thar Roxx |
| Base-variant | Not separately offered | Around ₹12.52 lakh |
| Mid-variant | Around ₹17.63 lakh | Around ₹16 – ₹19 lakh |
| Top-variant | Same single variant | Up to ₹23.52 lakh |
Those who are looking for a diesel 4WD Thar Roxx might find the Gurkha appealing as long as the mechanical off-roading capability is valued over high-end features.
Maruti Suzuki Jimny
The Maruti Suzuki Jimny is the smallest and most affordable alternative here. It uses a 1.5-litre naturally aspirated petrol engine producing around 105 PS and 134 Nm. Buyers can choose between a five-speed manual and a four-speed torque-converter automatic, while every version gets ALLGRIP PRO four-wheel drive with low range.
At 3,985 mm long and 1,645 mm wide, the Jimny is much smaller than the Thar Roxx. The small footprint makes it easy to drive through busy city streets, narrow mountain paths, and rugged off-road routes.
Why it is better than Mahindra Thar Roxx
The Jimny’s biggest advantage is affordable 4WD. Its entire range costs roughly ₹12.54 lakh to ₹14.67 lakh, so buyers can access proper four-wheel drive at a price where many Thar Roxx variants remain rear-wheel drive.
Jimny, in addition, is also much more fuel-efficient. The manual model is said to deliver 16.94 km/l, while the automatic gives 16.39 km/l. However, when it comes to power, the Jimny does not deliver much, and it can only carry four passengers while providing limited space in the cabin and for luggage. For people who want compactness, efficiency, and lower-priced off-roading, the Jimny is the best option.
Price Comparison: Maruti Suzuki Jimny vs. Mahindra Thar Roxx
The price of the Jimny is considerably lower than that of the Thar Roxx, and even the most expensive automatic version of the Jimny is priced way below that of a fully-loaded Roxx.
| Variant | Maruti Suzuki Jimny | Mahindra Thar Roxx |
| Base-variant | Around ₹12.54 lakh | Around ₹12.52 lakh |
| Mid-variant | Around ₹13.46 – ₹13.60 lakh | Around ₹16 – ₹19 lakh |
| Top-variant | Up to ₹14.67 lakh | Up to ₹23.52 lakh |
Also Read: Mahindra Thar vs Maruti Jimny: Real World Mileage Comparison
Summary
The Mahindra Thar Roxx remains one of the most capable lifestyle SUVs in its segment of the market, offering powerful engines, new features, a five-star Bharat NCAP safety rating, and proper off-road capability. However, Scorpio N, Gurkha 5 Door, and Jimny are all meant for various buyers.
Choose the Scorpio N for six- or seven-seat family practicality, the Gurkha 5 Door for serious off-road hardware, and the Jimny for affordable 4WD and better petrol mileage. The Thar Roxx remains the strongest all-rounder if you want a balance of performance, technology, comfort, and trail ability.
Related Reads:
BMW X1 LWB Alternatives: Competitors of BMW X1 LWB
Mahindra Thar Alternatives: Competitors of Mahindra Thar
Mahindra XUV700 Alternatives: Competitors of Mahindra XUV700
FAQs About Mahindra Thar Roxx Alternatives
Q. What are the best alternatives to the Mahindra Thar Roxx?
The Mahindra Scorpio N, Force Gurkha 5 Door, and Maruti Suzuki Jimny are among the best alternatives. The Scorpio N focuses on space, the Gurkha on off-road ability, and the Jimny on affordable 4WD.
Q. Is the Scorpio N better than the Thar Roxx?
The Scorpio N is better for buyers who need six or seven seats and a larger cabin. The Thar Roxx is more lifestyle-oriented and offers a strong mix of premium features, safety, and off-road technology.
Q. Which is better for off-roading, Thar Roxx or Gurkha 5 Door?
Both are capable, but the Gurkha 5 Door has an advantage in traditional mechanical hardware thanks to its front and rear differential locks and 700 mm water-wading ability.
Q. Is the Jimny cheaper than the Mahindra Thar Roxx?
Yes. The Jimny costs roughly ₹12.54 lakh to ₹14.67 lakh, while the Thar Roxx ranges from around ₹12.52 lakh to ₹23.52 lakh.
Q. Which Thar Roxx alternative offers the best mileage?
The Maruti Suzuki Jimny offers the best petrol mileage here, with up to 16.94 km/l for the manual. The Scorpio N diesel can return close to 16 km/l.
Q. Which Mahindra Thar Roxx alternative is best for families?
The Mahindra Scorpio N is the strongest option for families because it offers six- and seven-seat layouts, a larger cabin, powerful engines, and a broad range of comfort features.
