Comparison: Tata Sierra vs Mahindra Thar Roxx

Last updated 3 months ago
A comprehensive comparison of the Tata Sierra vs the Mahindra Thar ROXX, taking every key factor into account.
Tata Sierra vs Mahindra Thar Roxx
Last updated 3 months ago

While the Mahindra Thar ROXX is a great off-roader, most buy it for its show value, as its macho design commands respect on roads. Notably, the Tata Sierra falls within the same price bracket as the Mahindra Thar ROXX and is recognised as one of the most good-looking cars in India. Moreover, both the Sierra and Thar ROXX are 5-seater SUVs. Thereby, a buyer looking for a Mahindra Thar ROXX, especially for its design, can find the Tata Sierra a worthy alternative. If you are one such individual, or want to know how these beautiful SUVs compare, here is a comparison of the Tata Sierra vs the Mahindra Thar ROXX, taking every key factor into account.

Tata Sierra vs Mahindra Thar Roxx: Dimensions & Design

Tata Sierra
Tata Sierra
Tata SierraMahindra Thar Roxx
Length4,340 mm4,428 mm
Width1,841 mm1,870mm
Height1,715 mm1,923 mm
Wheelbase2,730 mm2,850 mm
Ground Clearance205 mm235 mm
Boot Space622 litres447 litres

The Mahindra Thar Roxx is 88 mm longer, 29 mm wider, 208 mm taller, and has a 120 mm longer wheelbase compared to the Tata Sierra. However, in reality, the Sierra is a more spacious 5-seater SUV than the Thar Roxx, mainly because the Sierra is built on a monocoque chassis, while the Thar Roxx is based on a ladder-frame chassis. While the rear seat of both SUVs offers ample shoulder room for three adults, the Sierra’s rear seat offers more leg room for the rear passengers. The Sierra also offers a significantly larger boot, while the Thar Roxx rides higher with 235 mm ground clearance.

Mahindra Thar Roxx
Mahindra Thar Roxx

Design is one of the strongest selling points of both the Tata Sierra and Mahindra Thar Roxx. As the Thar Roxx is primarily an off-roader, it looks like one. Up front, the aggressive, double-stacked six-slot grille with rounded headlamps and the muscular bumper give it a purposeful face. Adding to the SUV’s butch appeal are hood latches on the bonnet, exposed door hinges, and chunky door handles. Over to the side, the Thar Roxx boasts its macho attitude with its height, wider track, and offset wheels, including 19-inch diamond-cut alloy wheels, chunky wheel arch cladding, and massive tyres with a 789 mm outer diameter. At the rear, the Thar Roxx gets a side-opening tailgate with a full-size spare, and a rear windshield that opens independently and is hinged at the top. Overall, the Thar Roxx looks like a large, good-looking, sturdy off-roader.

Meanwhile, the Sierra looks attractive in a different way. Like the Thar Roxx, the Sierra gets a boxy silhouette, but it looks calmer and more sophisticated rather than rugged. Its front end features a high-set flat bonnet and a gloss-black upright bumper with a U-shaped silver skid plate. The SIERRA lettering is embossed on the gloss-black grille, atop which is a full-width LED light bar. To the side, the large rear window and quarter glass, combined with the black roof, mimic the ‘Alpine Window’ found on the original 1991 Sierra. At the rear, the boxy silhouette continues with a rather upright tailgate, while the dual-tone bumper and connected taillights add to the sleek appeal. Overall, due to the boxy silhouette, upright tailgate, and squared-off rear glass, the Sierra gives the impression of a high-end Land Rover Defender.

In terms of size, the Mahindra Thar Roxx is larger than the Tata Sierra. That said, the Tata Sierra is more spacious for 5 occupants and offers a significantly larger boot. Moreover, while both Mahindra Thar Roxx and Tata Sierra are high on show value, the Tata Sierra looks more like a fashionable mid-size SUV and the Mahindra Thar Roxx presents itself as a butch off-roader.

Tata Sierra vs Mahindra Thar Roxx: Engine & Transmission

Tata SierraMahindra Thar Roxx
Engine1.5-litre NA petrol engine
1.5-litre turbo petrol engine
1.5-litre turbo diesel engine
2-litre turbo petrol engine
2.2-litre turbo diesel engine

Power106 PS (NA petrol)
160 PS (turbo petrol)
118 PS (turbo diesel)
160 – 177 PS (turbo petrol)
150 – 175 PS (turbo diesel)
Torque145 Nm (NA petrol)
255 Nm (turbo petrol)
260 Nm (MT) – 280 Nm (AT) (turbo diesel)
330 – 380 Nm (turbo petrol)
330 – 370 Nm (turbo diesel)
Transmission6-speed manual gearbox with NA petrol and turbo-diesel engines.
7-speed DCT with NA petrol engine
6-speed torque converter automatic with turbo petrol and turbo diesel engines
6-speed manual gearbox and 6-speed torque converter automatic
MileageUp to 18 km/l (petrol)
Up to 20 km/l (diesel)
Up to 12.4 km/l (petrol)
Up to 15.2 km/l (diesel)

Clearly, the Mahindra Thar Roxx is substantially more powerful than the Tata Sierra. But since the Thar Roxx is larger and heavier than the Sierra, there is no major difference in their speed capabilities. However, the Sierra is more planted, and its steering offers better handling, making it more enjoyable to drive, especially with the turbo petrol engine. The other factor that favours the Sierra is its ride comfort. While the Sierra is up to the mark with ride quality Tata cars are known for, it delivers a significantly better ride quality than the Mahindra Thar Roxx. Another downside of the Thar Roxx is poor petrol mileage. While its 2-litre turbo petrol engine is the most powerful of the lot and delivers exciting performance, it is thirsty and has poor fuel efficiency.

Notably, the Sierra’s naturally aspirated petrol engine is weak. While it can comfortably meet day-to-day driving needs, it may not be ideal for someone who wants their SUV to accelerate quickly.

On the other hand, the Mahindra Thar Roxx is built on a ladder-frame chassis – a structure known for a bumpy, uneven ride. However, the Mahindra Thar Roxx is based on Mahindra’s fourth-generation (4G) body-on-frame chassis, an advanced form of the older third-gen chassis that underpins the 3-door Mahindra Thar. For the new fourth-gen chassis, Mahindra has used a stiffer, lighter ladder frame and a new multi-link suspension with Watt’s linkage to reduce body roll. They have changed the suspension mounting points and shifted the rear dampers to wider points for a better ride and improved body control. Moreover, the Thar Roxx gets electric power steering instead of the hydraulic power steering offered on the Mahindra Thar. With everything done for better ride quality, the Thar Roxx does offer a more comfortable ride than the 3-door Thar, but it’s still far from what can be called a family-friendly ride, as delivered by SUVs based on monocoque chassis like the Tata Sierra.

All the same, there is no denying that the Mahindra Thar Roxx is one of the best mass-market off-roaders. With off-road features such as a 4X4 drivetrain, an electronically locking rear differential, Smart Crawl, and Intelli Turn, the Thar Roxx can tackle challenging terrain with ease.

The Mahindra Thar Roxx is more powerful than the Tata Sierra. However, the Tata Sierra is more enjoyable to drive due to better aerodynamics and handling. Meanwhile, the Mahindra Thar Roxx towers over not only the Sierra but also all other cars in its segment when it comes to off-roading.

Tata Sierra vs Mahindra Thar Roxx: Features & Comfort

Tata SierraMahindra Thar Roxx
Infotainment system12.3-inch touchscreen infotainment system10.25-inch touchscreen infotainment system
Music system12-speaker JBL sound system9-speaker Harman Kardon sound system
Climate controlDual-zone AutomaticAutomatic
Ventilated seatsFront ventilated seatsFront ventilated seats
Adjustable steeringTilt and telescopicTilt adjust
Drive modesDrive modes: Eco, City, Sports
Terrain modes: Normal, Wet, Rough
Drive modes: Zip & Zoom
Terrain modes: Sand, Mud, Snow
Instrument cluster10.25-inch digital instrument cluster10.25-inch digital instrument cluster
SunroofPanoramic sunroofPanoramic sunroof
Adjustable seats (manual or electric)6-way powered driver seat with memory function6-way powered driver seat
Rear AC ventsAvailableAvailable
60:40 rear seat splitAvailableAvailable
Cruise controlAvailableAvailable
Tata Sierra interior
Tata Sierra interior

On the inside, both SUVs align with their innate character. As a premium family SUV, the Sierra has an upmarket interior layout, and the light-coloured upholstery and high-quality materials throughout the cabin enhance the feel-good factor. Interestingly, the Sierra has two different screen layouts. In the top variant, a triple-screen panel sits on the dashboard, consisting of a 12.3-inch main touchscreen infotainment display, a 12.3-inch touchscreen for the front passenger, and a 10.25-inch digital instrument cluster. Meanwhile, other variants get a separate touchscreen infotainment system and a digital instrument cluster, with no screen for the front passenger. Notably. The second-highest variant, Accomplished, has an Augmented Reality Head-Up Display, which is missing from the top variant with a triple-screen panel. In line with modern Tata cars, the Sierra features a gloss-black touch-sensitive HVAC panel that is easy to soil and less user-friendly than physical buttons.

Mahindra Thar Roxx interior
Mahindra Thar Roxx interior

Meanwhile, as an off-roader, the Thar Roxx prioritises functionality, featuring physical knobs and buttons for most functions. Mahindra has also ensured a family-friendly feel, using soft-touch materials on the dashboard and beige perforated leatherette upholstery on seats. Compared to the Sierra’s interior, the Thar Roxx’s interior is more old-school, with a touchscreen integrated into the dashboard and a traditional-looking digital instrument cluster set into a recess behind the steering wheel.

As for features, while both SUVs pack enough to enrich the ride, the Sierra is slightly better equipped than the Thar Roxx, with dual-zone climate control and a powered tailgate.

Inside, the Tata Sierra feels more modern, while the Mahindra Thar Roxx offers better practicality. Moreover, in terms of features, the Tata Sierra is better equipped than the Mahindra Thar Roxx.

Tata Sierra vs Mahindra Thar Roxx: Safety Features

Tata SierraMahindra Thar Roxx
NCAP Safety Rating5-star Bharat NCAP rating5-star Bharat NCAP rating
AirbagsSixSix
ABS with EBDYesYes
ESCYesYes
Traction ControlYesYes
Automatic headlampsYesYes
Rain-sensing WipersYesYes
Hill hold assistYesYes
Hill descent controlNoYes
Rear sensorsYesYes
Rear parking camera360-degree camera with 180-degree transparent mode360-degree camera
ISOFIX Child seat anchor pointsYesYes
ADASLevel-2 ADAS featuresLevel-2 ADAS features

Coming from the most renowned brands in the safety sector, both Tata Sierra and Mahindra Thar Roxx prioritise passenger safety. Both have scored a 5-star rating in the Bharat NCAP safety test and are among the safest cars in India. All the same, the Sierra’s 540-degree camera gives it a slight advantage over the Thar Roxx. The 540-degree camera is basically a 360-degree camera with an under-bonnet camera that provides a feed from beneath the SUV, so you can manoeuvre it in tight spaces and avoid potholes, rocks, and curbs.

Both the Tata Sierra and Mahindra Thar Roxx offer robust passenger safety.

Tata Sierra vs Mahindra Thar Roxx: Price comparison

Tata SierraMahindra Thar Roxx
Base variants (Ex-Showroom)Rs 11.49 – 12.99 lakhRs 12.39 – 13.86 lakh
Mid variants (Ex-Showroom)Rs 12.99 – 17.49 lakhRs 14.89 – 16.80 lakh
Upper mid variants (Ex-Showroom)Rs 15.29 – 18.49 lakhRs 16.52 – 21 lakh
Top variantRs 17.99 – 21.29 lakhRs 17.20 – 21.43 lakh

The Mahindra Thar Roxx is slightly more expensive than the Tata Sierra, especially in the higher variants. But the Mahindra Thar Roxx is a larger SUV, and its higher variants are equipped with off-road features, so the higher price is justified. As far as value for the money goes, given their prices and offerings, they are equal.

Tata Sierra vs Mahindra Thar Roxx: Which one should you buy

While the Tata Sierra and Mahindra Thar Roxx fall into the same price bracket and are both 5-seater SUVs, they differ significantly. The Tata Sierra is engineered for conventional use cases – day-to-day driving and trips with friends and family. In contrast, the Mahindra Thar Roxx is an off-roader. While Mahindra has made the Thar Roxx a better family car than the 3-door Thar, it does not offer the comfortable ride expected of a family SUV. All the same, if you want to own either of these two solely because of their design, it is totally your call.

Tata Sierra vs Mahindra Thar Roxx: FAQs

  1. Between the Tata Sierra and Mahindra Thar Roxx, which is larger?

    The Tata Sierra is 4,340 mm long, 1,841 mm wide, 1,715 mm tall, and has a wheelbase of 2,370 mm. Whereas the Mahindra Thar Roxx is 4,428 mm long, 1,870 mm wide, 1,923 mm tall, and has a 2,850 mm wheelbase. Therefore, the Thar Roxx is 88 mm longer, 29 mm wider, 208 mm taller, and has a 120 mm longer wheelbase compared to the Tata Sierra.

  2. Among the Tata Sierra and Mahindra Thar Roxx, which SUV is more powerful?

    The Tata Sierra’s 1.5-litre NA petrol engine produces 106 PS, the 1.5-litre turbo petrol engine produces 160 PS, and the 1.5-litre turbo diesel engine produces 118 PS. The Mahindra Thar Roxx’s 2-litre turbo petrol engine produces 160 -177 PS, and the 2.2-litre diesel engine produces 150–175 PS. Therefore, the Mahindra Thar Roxx is more powerful than the Tata Sierra.

  3. Among the Tata Sierra and the Mahindra Thar Roxx, which offers better sound quality?

    The Tata Sierra’s 12-speaker JBL sound system sounds slightly better than the Mahindra Thar Roxx’s 9-speaker Harman Kardon sound system.

  4. Between the Tata Sierra and the Mahindra Thar Roxx, which offers better ride quality?

    The Tata Sierra delivers a substantially better ride quality than the Mahindra Thar Roxx.

  5. What types of automatic transmission systems are available in the Tata Sierra and the Mahindra Thar Roxx?

    The Tata Sierra offers a 7-speed DCT automatic and a 6-speed torque converter automatic, while the Mahindra Thar Roxx offers a 6-speed torque converter automatic.

Share

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All Categories

A-Z Glossary

Every car part & feature, explained

News

The latest from the automotive world

Best Cars

The crème de la crème of cars

Rules & Regulations

Every law & regulation, explained

Car Ownership

Everyday car-care tips & advice

Buying a car

Make the right buying decision

Selling a car

Make the right selling decision

Miscellaneous

Cars & eveything in-between

5,000,000+ Readers

We’re ❤️ne big family!

Follow us for accurate, impartial & up-to-date information around everything related to cars – Latest news & developments, best options for every budget & lifestyle, ownership tips, buying & selling advice and a lot more on Spinny Magazine.

Unbiased
Rated 4.5 out of 5
Reliable
Rated 4.5 out of 5
Helpful
Rated 4.5 out of 5