Used Toyota vs Used Honda: Which is More Reliable Second Hand Car Brand in India?

Last updated 2 minutes ago
Toyota Urban Cruiser Ebella EV
Last updated 2 minutes ago

When purchasing a used car in India, reliability, comfort, and value for money are key considerations. The two popular names in the pre-owned car segment are Toyota and Honda, which are known for their reliable engines, practical design and overall good ownership experience. Toyota is known for its long-lasting vehicles and high resale values, and Honda has a reputation for its smooth engines, comfortable interiors, and fun-to-drive vehicles.

So, when comparing used toyota vs honda, which brand offers a better deal? Let’s compare their prices, features, maintenance costs, and overall ownership experience to help you make the right choice.

Used Toyota Quick Overview

Toyota has built a strong name in India for making cars that easily run past 1.5 lakh to 2 lakh kilometres with basic timely servicing. In the pre-owned market, popular Toyota cars include the Etios and Etios Liva for budget buyers, the Glanza and Urban Cruiser in the compact space, the Corolla Altis in the executive sedan class, and the Innova Crysta and Fortuner for big families.

Because toyota reliability is trusted by both family buyers and cab operators, used Toyota cars always stay in high demand. You will find plenty of options across different model years and fuel types on platforms like Spinny, though their resale prices stay higher than most rivals.

Also Read: Best Used Toyota Cars in India

ModelTransmissionPrice Range
Toyota Etios / Etios Liva (2013 – 2016)5-Speed Manual₹2.10 Lakh – ₹4.03 Lakh
Toyota Corolla Altis (2013 – 2018)6-Speed Manual / 7-Step CVT Automatic₹3.17 Lakh – ₹8.39 Lakh
Toyota Glanza (2019 – 2025)5-Speed Manual / CVT / 5-Speed AMT₹4.91 Lakh – ₹9.43 Lakh
Toyota Urban Cruiser / Hyryder (2021 – 2025)5-Speed Manual / 4-Speed & 6-Speed AT / e-CVT₹6.34 Lakh – ₹19.22 Lakh
Toyota Innova Crysta (2017 – 2022)5-Speed Manual / 6-Speed Torque Converter AT₹9.27 Lakh – ₹19.92 Lakh

Used Honda Quick Overview

Honda has long been a top pick for Indian buyers who want refined petrol engines, comfortable back seats, and clean styling. In the used car market, Honda’s main models are the Brio and Jazz hatchbacks, the Amaze compact sedan, the popular Honda City mid-size sedan, the WR-V crossover, and the newer Elevate SUV. Most of these cars come with Honda’s famous 1.2-litre and 1.5-litre i-VTEC petrol engines, while older models also offer a fuel-efficient 1.5-litre diesel engine.

Because Honda sedans and hatchbacks lose value faster in their early years than Toyota’s utility cars, buyers often get feature-packed, low-running Hondas at very good prices on platforms like Spinny.

Used Honda Cars

Also Read: How to Buy a Used Honda City

ModelTransmissionPrice Range
Honda Brio / Jazz (2013 – 2018)5-Speed Manual / 5-Speed AT / CVT Automatic₹1.84 Lakh – ₹3.98 Lakh
Honda Amaze (2014 – 2024)5-Speed Manual / CVT Automatic₹2.87 Lakh – ₹7.53 Lakh
Honda WR-V (2018 – 2022)5-Speed Manual / 6-Speed Manual₹4.57 Lakh – ₹6.68 Lakh
Honda City (2014 – 2024)5-Speed & 6-Speed Manual / CVT / e:HEV₹3.79 Lakh – ₹12.19 Lakh
Honda Elevate (2024)6-Speed Manual / CVT Automatic₹10.43 Lakh – ₹10.85 Lakh

Used Toyota vs Used Honda: Financing Comparison

If you plan to buy your car on a loan, your monthly budget will depend heavily on the car’s resale price. Let us look at how a standard 5-year used car loan works for two popular 2022 petrol automatic options on platforms like Spinny.

Loan ParameterUsed Toyota Glanza (2022 V AMT Petrol)Used Honda City (2022 ZX CVT Petrol)
Down Payment₹1,30,000₹1,80,000
Loan Tenure5 Years (60 Months)5 Years (60 Months)
Loan Amount₹5,20,000₹7,20,000
Interest Rate12.99% p.a.12.99% p.a.
Interest Amount₹1,90,035₹2,63,126
Total Paid (Down Payment + Principal + Interest)₹8,40,035₹11,63,126
DifferenceBase Benchmark+ ₹3,23,091 (Mid-size City costs more up front and overall)

Because a mid-size sedan like the Honda City sits in a higher segment than a compact hatchback like the Glanza, you end up borrowing more money and paying higher interest over five years.

Also Read: How to Buy a Used Toyota Innova

Used Toyota vs Used Honda: Insurance Comparison

Insurance is another key part of your yearly running cost. Your premium mainly depends on the car’s Insured Declared Value (IDV), engine size, age, and policy type. Most popular models from both brands like the Glanza, Amaze, Urban Cruiser, and City have engines under 1500cc, so their basic third-party insurance rates are the same. Only big SUVs and MPVs like the Innova Crysta and Fortuner fall into the higher engine slab.

5-Year Insured Value & Insurance Premium Breakdown

Insurance ParameterUsed Toyota Urban Cruiser (2021 1.5 Petrol)Used Honda City (2021 1.5 Petrol)
Initial Purchase Price₹6,50,000₹7,25,000
Starting IDV (Year 1)₹5,85,000₹6,50,000
Estimated IDV (Year 5)₹3,55,000₹3,80,000
Year 1 Premium (Comprehensive)₹15,800₹17,400
Year 2 Premium (Comprehensive)₹13,600₹14,800
Year 3 Premium (Comprehensive)₹11,800₹12,700
Year 4 Premium (Comprehensive / TP)₹10,200₹10,900
Year 5 Premium (Comprehensive / TP)₹8,800₹9,300
Total 5-Year Insurance Cost (Approx.)₹60,200₹65,100
Insurance Cost DifferenceBase Benchmark+ ₹4,900 (Higher initial purchase price raises Honda City’s insurance slightly)

Note: Based on 2021 mid-to-top spec 1.5L petrol variants over a 5-year ownership period applying standard annual IDV depreciation.

Also Read: Best Used Honda Cars in India

Used Toyota vs Used Honda: Key Differences

Here are some simple points to consider when choosing between a used Toyota and a used Honda:

  • Infotainment System: Toyota’s newer vehicle models such as the Glanza and Hyryder are equipped with touchscreen systems that also have wireless phone connectivity. Older models such as the Etios come with simple music systems. Easy-to-use touchscreens have also been a feature in Honda City and Amaze models since 2017, but the older ones are less equipped.
  • Comfort: Honda’s cars such as the City and Jazz feature comfortable seats and decent leg space for back-seat riders. Toyota’s emphasis is on the upright seating posture, improved road visibility, and hardy cabin fabrics with a ‘wear and tear’ tolerance.
  • Features: Sunroofs, blind-spot cameras and advanced safety systems are among the features added to newer Honda models such as the 5th-generation City and Elevate in select variants. Features like 360-degree cameras, strong-hybrid technology, and a heads-up display are available on Toyota models like the Hyryder.
  • Safety: Both brands have excellent safety features. The Toyota Etios, Urban Cruiser and Hyryder have all been rated 4-star by Global NCAP, as have the Honda Jazz, 4th-gen City and 2nd-gen Amaze.
  • Performance and Practicality: Honda’s petrol engines feel lively and smooth, especially with CVT automatic gearboxes in city traffic. Buyers also love honda reliability because these engines stay smooth and trouble-free even after years of daily driving. Toyota tunes its engines more for easy pulling power, good mileage, and long engine life.
  • Price and Ownership: Used Toyota cars tend to be more expensive due to their resale value and high price. The used Honda car is typically more cost-effective, giving you a bigger sedan or a higher-quality car for the same price.

To sum up, if you want a strong car that will have a great resale value, you should opt for Toyota. If you’re looking for a more refined driving experience, interior comfort, and a lower purchase price, Honda is a better option. Before deciding, always do a car service history check, a car accident check, a kilometres driven check and a car condition check.

Buy a Used Toyota or Used Honda with Spinny

Whether you pick a Toyota for its long life or a Honda for its comfort and value, buying a pre-owned car is much easier with Spinny. Every car goes through a strict 200-point check to verify its engine, safety, and overall health before it reaches you.

Spinny also gives you several helpful benefits for a worry-free purchase:

  • Thorough Inspection: Every car passes a 200-point check and refurbishment process to meet Spinny’s quality standards.
  • Warranty: Get a 1-year warranty for complete peace of mind.
  • 5-Day Money-Back Guarantee: You can return the car within 5 days, subject to applicable terms and conditions.
  • Convenient Test Drives: Book a test drive right at your home within 10 km of a Spinny Car Hub.
  • Easy Financing: Get simple used-car loan options to fit your monthly budget.

With fixed, transparent prices and inspected cars, Spinny helps you find the right used Toyota or used Honda without any hidden surprises.

Also Read: Should You Buy a Used Honda City?

Spare Parts, Maintenance & Long-Term Ownership Reality

Many buyers worry about upkeep costs once a car’s factory warranty ends. Both Japanese brands have strong service networks across India, making them top benchmarks for second hand car reliability, though there are a few small differences in day-to-day maintenance:

  • Toyota Spare Parts & Maintenance: Toyota service centres are known for clear, fixed-price service bills and long-lasting parts like clutches and brake pads. Even for older models like the Etios and Corolla Altis, spare parts are easy to find at both company workshops and local garages.
  • Honda Spare Parts & Maintenance: Regular servicing for cars like the Amaze and City is easy on the pocket and similar to other mass-market brands. However, Honda’s soft suspension can wear out a bit faster on broken roads, and body panels or automatic gearbox parts on older models can cost slightly more.
Used Toyota Cars

Summary: Which One is the Better Deal Today?

In the second-hand market, both Toyota and Honda are good investments. It all depends on your budget and how you intend to use the car.

Used Toyota

When it comes to a tough car that will be dependable daily, can endure bad roads and still be in good shape for the next five to seven years, it is time for a used Toyota. Popular models such as the Glanza or the Innova Crysta will cost slightly more, but you will recover the extra cost in terms of low repair costs and high resale value.

Used Honda

For those who are looking for a smooth-running petrol engine, comfortable seats, state-of-the-art features and excellent value for money today, a used Honda is the better choice. Cars such as the Honda City and Amaze depreciate at a higher rate during the first few years of their life, which means you can get the benefit of owning a top-of-the-range, comfortable vehicle while paying a low price for it.

Overall, choose Toyota for maximum durability and resale value; choose Honda for driving comfort and getting more features for your budget.

Related Reads:
Top 10 Most Reliable Cars in India
5 Cars with the Best Resale Value in India
3 Things to Check Before Buying a Used Honda City

FAQs About Used Toyota vs Used Honda Cars

  1. Q1. Which lasts longer in India: a used Toyota or a used Honda?

    Both Toyota & Honda cars will last well beyond 1.5 lakh km if serviced regularly and well looked after. However, Toyota’s Innova Crysta, Fortuner & Corolla Altis have a reputation for being very reliable and can reach beyond 2 lakh km.

  2. Q2. Are used Honda cars cheaper to buy than used Toyota cars?

    Yes, generally they are. Toyota cars have a higher resale value, so you can expect to pay a lower price for a 4-5 year old Honda City or Amaze than a similar-aged Toyota. This means you will also get improved features and more space in the same budget.

  3. Q3. Which brand has lower annual maintenance costs?

    Both cars will have similar running costs. Petrol Hatchbacks & Sedans will require servicing once a year, which can cost about ₹5,000 – ₹8,000. This really depends on how well the car has been looked after, how old it is and how much it has been driven.

  4. Q4. Are CVT automatics in used Honda cars reliable?

    Honda’s CVT automatic gearbox is well known for being smooth and reliable. It is important to look at the service history and ensure that the oil in the gears has been changed as recommended.

  5. Q5. Which is better for highway driving: a used Toyota or a used Honda?

    Both are great options. A used Honda City will provide you with great comfort, smooth performance and easy handling. On the other hand, a Toyota Innova Crysta is better suited for family trips, extra luggage, and long journeys with more passengers.

Share

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

All Categories

A-Z Glossary

Every car part & feature, explained

News

The latest from the automotive world

Best Cars

The crème de la crème of cars

Rules & Regulations

Every law & regulation, explained

Car Ownership

Everyday car-care tips & advice

Buying a car

Make the right buying decision

Selling a car

Make the right selling decision

Miscellaneous

Cars & eveything in-between

5,000,000+ Readers

We’re ❤️ne big family!

Follow us for accurate, impartial & up-to-date information around everything related to cars – Latest news & developments, best options for every budget & lifestyle, ownership tips, buying & selling advice and a lot more on Spinny Magazine.

Unbiased
Rated 4.5 out of 5
Reliable
Rated 4.5 out of 5
Helpful
Rated 4.5 out of 5