Honda Amaze and Honda City are two sedans that attract different types of buyers. The Amaze is an affordable, compact sedan ideal for daily city driving, while the City is known for its premium features, spacious interior, and smooth performance. Customers choose either a new Amaze or a used City based on their budget and needs.
The 4th-generation Honda City, renowned for its comfort and performance, was discontinued in India as Honda shifted its focus to the new 5th-generation model, which features a redesigned look and improved specifications. The discontinuation also occurred alongside stricter emission regulations and shifting consumer preferences toward purchasing used 4th-generation City models or the newer Amaze.
This guide aims to help buyers compare the pros and cons of purchasing a new Honda Amaze versus a used 4th-generation Honda City, enabling them to make a financially informed decision based on factors such as price, features, maintenance costs, and overall value.
Table of Contents
New Honda Amaze Quick Overview
The new Honda Amaze is a modern and practical city car with excellent overall capability. The recent 2024 mid-life facelift updates its exterior with a new design, sleek LED headlights, and enhanced interior features, boosting comfort and convenience for both passengers and drivers.
This third-generation Amaze features enhanced safety options, including advanced driver assistance systems, as well as fuel-efficient 1.2-litre petrol and diesel engines. With a focus on technology and efficiency, the 2024 facelift positions the Amaze as a strong contender in the competitive compact sedan market.
Key Updates of the New Honda Amaze
The 2024 Honda Amaze facelift features a new design inspired by the Honda Elevate SUV, with a more prominent hexagonal grille, slim LED projector headlights, and signature Z-shaped LED taillights. New alloy wheels and redesigned bumpers enhance its sporty and fresh look, making it stand out among compact sedans.
Inside, the Amaze offers a luxurious cabin experience with an 8-inch floating touchscreen that supports wireless Apple CarPlay and Android Auto. It also features a semi-digital instrument cluster, updated steering wheel controls, and advanced safety features, including six airbags and advanced driver assistance systems (ADAS), making it one of the safest and most technologically advanced vehicles in its class.
Here are the significant changes in the 2024 Honda Amaze facelift:
- Electronic Stability Control (ESC) has been added for improved vehicle stability.
- The Traction Control System (TCS) was introduced to provide better grip on slippery roads.
- Lane Watch Camera provides a live feed of the vehicle’s left blind spot.
- Wireless phone charger in top variants for a clutter-free charging experience.
- Rear AC vents have been added to enhance comfort for rear passengers.
These updates boost safety, convenience, and comfort in the latest Amaze model.
Here are the ex-showroom prices for the new Honda Amaze:
| New Honda Amaze Ex-Showroom Price | ||
| Car Variant | Transmission | Price |
| Amaze V 1.2 Petrol MT | Manual | ₹8.09 Lakh |
| Amaze VX 1.2 Petrol MT | Manual | ₹9.19 Lakh |
| Amaze Elite Pack VX 1.2 Petrol MT | Manual | ₹9.19 Lakh |
| Amaze V 1.2 Petrol CVT | Automatic (CVT) | ₹9.34 Lakh |
| Amaze ZX 1.2 Petrol MT | Manual | ₹9.99 Lakh |
| Amaze VX 1.2 Petrol CVT | Automatic (CVT) | ₹10.14 Lakh |
| Amaze Elite Pack VX 1.2 Petrol CVT | Automatic (CVT) | ₹10.14 Lakh |
| Amaze ZX 1.2 Petrol CVT | Automatic (CVT) | ₹11.19 Lakh |
Used Honda City Quick Overview
The pre-owned Honda City, 4th generation, has been sold in India since 2014. Over the years, it has received two major facelifts in 2017 and 2020, which refreshed its look and added new features, keeping it modern and up to date. These updates included improvements in safety, technology, and comfort, allowing the City to remain competitive in the mid-size sedan market for nearly a decade.
The 4th-generation Honda City has a strong sales record in India, selling over 8 lakh units since its launch. Its combination of reliability, spacious interiors, and smooth performance has earned it a loyal following. As a used car, the City remains popular among buyers seeking a premium sedan experience without paying a premium price for a new vehicle.
Here is the price range for the used Honda City, along with its model name and transmission:
| Model Name | Transmission | Approximate Price (Last Recorded) |
| City 4th Generation i-VTEC S | Manual | ₹8.77 Lakh |
| City 4th Generation SV MT | Manual | ₹9.50 Lakh |
| City 4th Generation Edge Edition SV | Manual | ₹9.75 Lakh |
| City 4th Generation i-VTEC SV | Manual | ₹9.91 Lakh |
| City 4th Generation V MT | Manual | ₹10 Lakh |
| City 4th Generation i-VTEC V | Manual | ₹10.66 Lakh |
| Edge Edition Diesel SV | Manual | ₹11.10 Lakh |
| City 4th Generation i-DTEC SV | Manual | ₹11.11 Lakh |
| City 4th Generation i-VTEC VX | Manual | ₹11.82 Lakh |
| City 4th Generation VX MT | Manual | ₹11.82 Lakh |
| City 4th Generation i-DTEC V | Manual | ₹11.91 Lakh |
| City 4th Generation i-VTEC CVT V | Automatic | ₹12.01 Lakh |
| City 4th Generation V CVT | Automatic | ₹12.01 Lakh |
| City 4th Generation i-VTEC ZX | Manual | ₹13.01 Lakh |
| City 4th Generation ZX MT | Manual | ₹13.01 Lakh |
| City 4th Generation i-DTEC VX | Manual | ₹13.02 Lakh |
| City 4th Generation i-VTEC CVT VX | Automatic | ₹13.12 Lakh |
| City 4th Generation VX CVT | Automatic | ₹13.12 Lakh |
| Anniversary i-VTEC CVT ZX | Automatic | ₹13.80 Lakh |
| Anniversary i-DTEC ZX | Manual | ₹13.93 Lakh |
| City 4th Generation i-DTEC ZX | Manual | ₹14.21 Lakh |
| City 4th Generation i-VTEC CVT ZX | Automatic | ₹14.31 Lakh |
| City 4th Generation ZX CVT | Automatic | ₹14.31 Lakh |
New Honda Amaze vs Used Honda City: Financing Comparison
When comparing financing for a new 2024 Honda Amaze and a used 2022 Honda City, the Amaze generally requires a lower loan amount due to its more affordable price. With interest rates ranging around 10%, the monthly EMIs for the Amaze fall around ₹17,590 over a 5-year tenure, making it easier on the budget.
The used Honda City, priced around ₹11.49 lakh, will require a larger loan and higher EMI payments, ranging around ₹21,114 per month, with interest rates slightly higher at 10.99%. While it comes with premium features, it’s essential to consider the financing costs of the used car and potential maintenance expenses before making a decision.
Here’s an example comparison of the Honda Amaze V 1.2 Petrol MT, priced at ₹10.39 lakh, and a used Honda City, priced at ₹11.49 lakh, at a 10% rate of interest and 5-year tenure:
| New Honda Amaze Financing | Used Honda City Financing | |
| Down Payment | ₹2,12,026 | ₹2,32,000 |
| Loan Tenure | 5 year | 5 year |
| Loan Amount | ₹8,27,910 | ₹9,28,000 |
| Interest Rate | 10% | 10.99% |
| Interest Amount | ₹2,27,490 | ₹3,38,840 |
| Total Paid | ₹10,55,400 | ₹12,66,840 |
| Difference | ₹16,400 (Approx) | ₹1,17,840 (Approx) |
New Honda Amaze vs Used Honda City: Insurance Comparison
The new 2024 Honda Amaze generally has lower insurance costs over five years, with annual premiums starting around ₹15,000 and going up to ₹25,000 for base models and ₹16,000 to ₹35,000 for higher variants. This totals roughly ₹75,000 to ₹1.75 lakh over a five-year period. The car’s full manufacturer warranty, minimal depreciation, and new condition contribute to more affordable premiums and lower risk for insurers.
In comparison, the used 2022 Honda City commands higher annual insurance premiums of approximately ₹21,800 to ₹27,100. This amounts to around ₹1.09 to ₹1.35 lakh over five years. Factors such as the vehicle’s age, depreciation, and potential wear and tear can all contribute to these costs.
Ultimately, the Amaze offers cost-effective insurance and peace of mind with its warranty, while the City delivers a premium experience at a moderately higher insurance cost.
New Honda Amaze vs Used Honda City: Which to Choose?
If you’re seeking an affordable option with lower upfront and ongoing costs, the new Honda Amaze is an excellent choice. It features the latest technology, better fuel efficiency, and a full manufacturer’s warranty, providing peace of mind and reliable daily commuting. This makes it ideal for those who want a practical and hassle-free ownership experience without sacrificing modern comforts.
The second-hand Honda City, on the other hand, offers a more luxurious cabin, ample space, and improved performance. It’s ideal for customers who value comfort and a smooth ride. However, higher purchase prices, increased insurance costs, and potential maintenance expenses make ownership more expensive over time. Therefore, careful budgeting is essential before choosing this option.
Ultimately, your choice depends on what you prioritise. If price, warranty, and fuel efficiency are your main concerns, the new Amaze is the better option. However, if a premium-segment experience and being willing to spend more over time matter to you, the used City offers a more refined ride with luxury features that might justify the extra cost.
FAQ About New Honda Amaze vs Used Honda City
Q. Which offers better value for money, the new Honda Amaze or the used Honda City?
The new Honda Amaze offers newer features, a warranty, and peace of mind, while the used Honda City provides a premium segment experience at a slightly higher price. Your choice depends on whether you prefer brand-new dependability or a luxury feel at a lower cost.
Q. How does performance compare between the new Honda Amaze and the used Honda City?
The used Honda City generally offers better performance with a more powerful engine and smoother acceleration. Meanwhile, the new Honda Amaze is lightweight and more fuel-efficient, making it ideal for daily city commuting. Your performance needs will determine which one is better suited for you.
Q. Which is more comfortable, the new Honda Amaze or the used Honda City?
The used Honda City features a roomier interior, improved legroom, and enhanced ride quality, making it particularly suitable for road trips. On the other hand, the new Amaze offers decent comfort for its size, but it feels more cramped compared to the City’s spacious interior.
Q. Are maintenance costs higher for the new Honda Amaze or the used Honda City?
The new Honda Amaze will require minimal maintenance during the first few years of warranty. Meanwhile, the used Honda City may require more frequent servicing due to its age and mileage. However, Honda’s maintenance costs remain affordable for both the used and new Honda City models.
Q. Which has better resale value, the new Honda Amaze or the used Honda City?
The new Honda Amaze depreciates faster in its first few years. On the other hand, the used Honda City can retain its value better in the short term, as most depreciation occurs before purchase if it was bought at a fair market price.
