In recent years, the automotive landscape has undergone significant changes with the advent of electric vehicles, not just across the globe – with around 14% of all new cars sold worldwide in 2022 being electric – but also in the Indian subcontinent. Here’s a quick stat – around 1.76 lakh electric cars were sold in India in 2025, up 77% from the year before. Clearly, traditional petrol and diesel vehicles are being challenged by their electric counterparts due to lower running and maintenance costs in addition to the environmental benefits. And numbers are only going up from here on. So, as this industry evolves, the EV vs petrol vs diesel debate continues to intensify and for potential buyers, a comprehensive total cost of ownership analysis becomes increasingly important. This article delves into a detailed breakdown of costs associated with each type of vehicle over various periods and usage patterns, helping you make an informed decision about which vehicle best suits your needs. We also look at new EV vs used petrol car, for buyers weighing a brand-new electric car against a pre-owned petrol one.
Table of Contents
Petrol Cars vs Diesel Cars vs Electric Cars: Cost of Purchase
A great vehicle for this comparative analysis would be the widely popular Tata Nexon with its petrol, diesel, and electric variant offerings. Since its launch in the year 2020, more than 85,000 Nexon EVs have been registered in India (2020–2025, Vahan data), evidently making it one of India’s preferred choices when it comes to electric cars, with a competitive range and relative affordability. For this article, let’s look at the Creative+ and Fearless trims across petrol AMT, petrol DCA, diesel AMT, electric medium range (30 kWh) and electric long range (45 kWh) types, starting with the cost of purchase.
| Petrol AMT | Petrol DCA | Diesel AMT | Electric MR (30 kWh) | Electric LR (45 kWh) | |
| Creative + | 11,16,000 | 12,66,000 | 12,19,000 | 12,49,000 | 14,34,000 |
| Fearless + | – | 13,76,000 | 14,09,000 | 13,29,000 | 15,34,000 |
The initial cost of the Nexon EV variants is still higher than the petrol versions, but the gap has narrowed sharply. At the Creative+ level, the 30 kWh Nexon EV costs about Rs 1.33 lakh more than the petrol AMT and only about Rs 30,000 more than the diesel AMT. Part of the reason is tax: since September 2025, small petrol and diesel cars attract 18% GST, while EVs continue at 5%. Diesel models command a slight premium over petrol, while the long-range EV remains the most expensive, reflecting the higher cost of its bigger battery.
Petrol Cars vs Diesel Cars vs Electric Cars: Efficiency & Cost
| Mileage | Range | |
| Petrol | 17.18 kmpl | up to 755.92 km |
| Diesel | 24.08 kmpl | up to 1059.52 km |
| Electric MR (30 kWh) | 10.83 km/kWh | up to 325 km |
| Electric LR (45 kWh) | 10.87 km/kWh | up to 489 km |
Let’s compare mileage and range across the variants against the price tags they come with.
With a full tank capacity of 44L, the petrol and diesel variants can allow you competitive distances of up to 755.92 km and 1059.52 km respectively. Diesel variants shine with their impressive mileage, ideal for long-distance travel enthusiasts. Petrol counterparts offer a balanced blend of affordability and performance, suited for daily urban commutes. Electric variants, while exhibiting lower range figures, showcase their potential for reduced operating costs over time. On a full charge, the medium range and long range Nexon EVs cover about 57% and 35% less distance respectively than the petrol Nexon does on a full tank.
Mileage in km/l and efficiency in km/kWh cannot be compared directly, as they measure different things. So ICE vehicles, especially diesel cars, clearly steal the show when it comes to range, while EVs win on what each kilometre costs.
Let’s assume a driving range of 1000 kms over a month and compare costs of fuel or power for 1, 5, 10 and finally even 15 years across these 3 vehicle types.
| Petrol | Diesel | Electric MR | Electric LR | |
| 1 Year Range | 12000 km | 12000 km | 12000 km | 12000 km |
| Mileage | 17.18 km/L | 24.08 km/L | 10.83 km/kWh | 10.87 km/kWh |
| 1 Year Fuel / Charging Cost (in Rs.) | 71,329 | 47,442 | 8,862 | 8,834 |
| 5 Year Fuel / Charging Cost (in Rs.) | 3,56,647 | 2,37,209 | 44,308 | 44,172 |
| 10 Year Fuel / Charging Cost (in Rs.) | 7,13,295 | 4,74,419 | 88,615 | 88,344 |
| 15 Year Fuel / Charging Cost (in Rs.) | 10,69,942 | 7,11,628 | 1,32,923 | 1,32,515 |
*Petrol – Rs 102.12/litre, Diesel – Rs 95.20/litre (New Delhi, 6 November 2026), EV charging – Rs 8/unit at home.
However, if you zoom out and examine these ranges in the larger picture, the per-unit cost for charging an electric vehicle at home is nearly 13 times lower than the per litre cost of petrol and therefore, that ultimately allows you to drive more while also taking it easy on your bank balance. So over the course of a year, for the same exact distance, you’d be spending about 8 times more on fuelling up the petrol-powered Nexon than you would on charging your Nexon EV. Public fast charging costs considerably more per unit than home charging, which narrows this gap.
It’s safe to say that when it comes to running costs, the electric variants distinctly outshine their fuel powered competitors simply owing to the fact that charging these vehicles costs a whole lot less than your regular petrol or diesel costs. Here, diesel powered variants provide a good balance on the mileage for their associated fuel cost, however, still remain unbeatable by EV unit charge costs.
Petrol Cars vs Diesel Cars vs Electric Cars: Maintenance Cost
Here’s another winning point for team EV – maintenance costs. A lot of the engine maintenance costs that come with our petrol and diesel vehicles simply don’t exist with the electric cars, as there is no engine oil, clutch or exhaust system to look after. Not only that, but EVs also have far fewer moving parts in their drivetrain than conventional ICE vehicles. Therefore, electric cars tend to need fewer repairs than petrol or diesel cars, with tyre replacements, brakes and routine checks being the primary focus rather than filter replacements, oil changes, fuel and transmission system inspections etc. This table, which weighs up estimated maintenance costs across the Nexon Petrol, Nexon Diesel and Nexon EV, shows the substantial differences across variants when it comes to costs associated with vehicle servicing and maintenance.
Variant | Tata Nexon Petrol | Tata Nexon Diesel | Tata Nexon EV |
| 1st Year Service | 4446 | 5975 | 3000 |
| 2nd Year Service | 4446 | 5975 | 3000 |
| 3rd Year Service | 5928 | 7458 | 3000 |
| 4th Year Service | 4446 | 5975 | 3000 |
| 5th Year Service | 4827 | 5975 | 3000 |
| Total Maintenance Cost over 5 Years | 24093 | 31358 | 15000 |
The need to spend on a variety of aspects is eliminated with EVs owing to mechanical differences, allowing you to save more than half the amount if you compare diesel cars with electric ones, while petrol cars cost roughly 1.6 times as much to maintain as electric ones. Evidently, diesel variants cost the most to maintain with petrol giving a good balance between the two but again, the savings on EV maintenance are considerably great, making it a competitive choice across the variants.
Petrol Cars vs Diesel Cars vs Electric Cars: Cost of Running
Now that we have a fair breakdown of the costs associated with fuelling up or charging along with the services and repairs factored in as well, we can get a better picture of the total cost of ownership over a 5 year period. For a like-for-like comparison, we have used the Creative+ level prices with petrol AMT, diesel AMT and both EV battery options.
| Variant | Tata Nexon Petrol AMT | Tata Nexon Diesel AMT | Tata Nexon EV MR | Tata Nexon EV LR |
| Purchase Cost (ex-showroom) | 11,16,000 | 12,19,000 | 12,49,000 | 14,34,000 |
| 5 Year Fuel / Charging Cost | 3,56,647 | 2,37,209 | 44,308 | 44,172 |
| 5 Year Maintenance Cost | 24,093 | 31,358 | 15,000 | 15,000 |
| Total Cost over 5 Years (12000 km a year) | 14,96,740 | 14,87,567 | 13,08,308 | 14,93,172 |
Over a period of 5 years, the medium range Nexon EV is the most economical option of all, costing about Rs 1.8 lakh less than the petrol and diesel versions. The long range EV ends up level with the petrol and diesel, as its higher purchase price cancels out its fuel savings over this period. As is evident, the purchase price of EVs accounts for a major portion of their overall expense, which is why the costs level up over time, indicating that once bought, you are in for a good ride of savings as compared to petrol and diesel cars. Greater production and innovation are likely to bring the cost of batteries down, which would in turn reduce the purchasing cost of electric cars and give petrol and diesel variants fierce competition. Note that these figures do not include insurance, registration or resale value.
Petrol Cars vs Diesel Cars vs Electric Cars: Variable Cost of Ownership
With a good understanding of the total running costs across variants, let’s look at some use cases to examine this situation under different driving ranges so you can compare the three vehicle types according to what caters to your driving needs. We’ve picked three monthly ranges of 500 kms, 1000 kms, and lastly 2000 kms which leads to 6000 kms, 12000 kms and 24000 kms respectively, over a year’s time
| Monthly distance | Period | Petrol AMT | Diesel AMT | EV MR (30 kWh) | EV LR (45 kWh) |
| 500 km | 5 years | 13.18 | 13.69 | 12.86 | 14.71 |
| 500 km | 10 years | 15.21 | 15.19 | 13.23 | 15.08 |
| 500 km | 15 years | 17.23 | 16.69 | 13.60 | 15.45 |
| 1000 km | 5 years | 14.97 | 14.88 | 13.08 | 14.93 |
| 1000 km | 10 years | 18.77 | 17.56 | 13.68 | 15.52 |
| 1000 km | 15 years | 22.58 | 20.25 | 14.27 | 16.12 |
| 2000 km | 5 years | 18.53 | 17.25 | 13.53 | 15.37 |
| 2000 km | 10 years | 25.91 | 22.31 | 14.56 | 16.41 |
| 2000 km | 15 years | 33.28 | 27.36 | 15.60 | 17.44 |
Here’s what we can say from the table above:
At current prices, the 30 kWh Nexon EV works out cheapest in every scenario, even if you drive only 500 kms a month. At that distance, though, the gap over petrol over five years is small, at around Rs 32,000, so a petrol car remains a sensible choice for light users who want the lowest purchase price.
For the ideal/average driving range of 1000 kms monthly, an electric vehicle with battery capacity similar to the Nexon EV MR, i.e., 30 kWh, is your best bet, where you consistently save over time periods of 5, 10 and 15 years. Diesel vehicles take the second spot over five years, while the long-range EV moves into second place over 10 and 15 years.
For longer driving ranges, your best option is yet again electric vehicles with battery capacities of 30 kWh and then 45 kWh. In this case, petrol cars are significantly pricier over the span of 5, 10 and 15 years.
New Electric Car vs Used Petrol Car: Total Cost Comparison in India
Many buyers are not choosing between a new EV and a new petrol car, but between a new EV and a used petrol car that costs much less upfront. Here, the new EV vs used petrol car question comes down to how much you drive, because the EV starts with a big price gap that it then has to recover through cheaper running costs.
To keep the comparison simple, we have compared a new Nexon EV Creative+ (30 kWh) at about Rs 13.33 lakh on-road in Delhi with a used 2023 Nexon petrol automatic, which was listed on Spinny for around Rs 8.71 lakh. We have used the same fuel, charging and maintenance assumptions as above, over five years.
| Monthly distance | Used Nexon petrol (5-year cost) | New Nexon EV MR (5-year cost) | Cheaper option |
| 1,000 km | Rs 12.52 lakh | Rs 13.92 lakh | Used petrol, by about Rs 1.41 lakh |
| 1,500 km | Rs 14.30 lakh | Rs 14.14 lakh | Roughly equal |
| 2,000 km | Rs 16.08 lakh | Rs 14.37 lakh | New EV, by about Rs 1.72 lakh |
*Includes purchase price, fuel or home-charging cost and maintenance. Insurance, resale value and the higher maintenance an older petrol car may need are not included.
On these numbers, the break-even point is about 1,450 km a month. Below that, a used petrol car usually has the lower total cost of ownership, simply because you pay so much less upfront. Above it, the new EV’s running cost of about Rs 0.74 per km, against about Rs 5.94 per km for petrol, starts to win.
A few other things can tip the balance. The electric car cost advantage depends on charging at home; if you rely mostly on public fast chargers, the savings shrink. A used petrol car will also need more maintenance as it gets older, while a new EV comes with a full warranty, including on its battery. On the other hand, a used car loses value more slowly in absolute terms, and you avoid the steepest part of a new car’s depreciation. Every used car on Spinny goes through a 200-point inspection and comes with Fixed Price Assurance, so you know what you are paying for.
Which Should You Buy?
Given all of the context paired with this comprehensive cost-benefit analysis, purchasing an electric car proves to be a smart choice for many buyers, especially those who drive a lot and can charge at home. While in the short run, petrol and diesel cars can seem like the prime candidates, in the longer run, they come with some serious costs unlike their electric counterparts, where running costs are a fraction of what you would spend on fuel.
Deciding between petrol, diesel, and electric vehicles (EVs) hinges on several key factors: initial cost, fuel efficiency, maintenance, and usage patterns.
Petrol cars are the most affordable to purchase initially, making them a good choice for those with lower budgets or who plan to keep their vehicle for a shorter period. They are ideal for daily urban commutes and shorter distances, as they offer decent performance and lower maintenance costs compared to diesel engines. However, petrol cars incur higher fuel expenses over time, which can add up if you drive frequently.
Diesel cars, while more expensive upfront, offer superior fuel efficiency and are more economical for long-distance travel. They provide better mileage, making them suitable for those who drive over 15,000 km annually. However, diesel engines are more complex and require higher maintenance, which can increase overall ownership costs. Additionally, regulatory restrictions in some regions, such as the NCR’s ban on diesel vehicles older than ten years, may limit their long-term viability.
Electric vehicles (EVs), despite their higher initial purchase price, offer substantial savings on fuel and maintenance in the long run. They’re cheaper to operate due to lower electricity costs and have fewer moving parts, reducing the likelihood of costly repairs. Technological advancements and increased production are expected to drive down battery costs, making them more affordable over time. Buying a second-hand EV can also be a cost-effective option, though it is worth checking the battery’s health and remaining warranty before you buy. EVs are an excellent choice for those looking to invest in a sustainable and cost-effective vehicle for the long term, especially as government incentives and infrastructure improvements continue to support their adoption.
In summary, the right vehicle for you depends on your driving habits and financial priorities. Petrol cars are best for short-term ownership and lower annual mileage, and a used petrol car is often the cheapest option overall if you drive less than about 1,450 km a month. Diesel cars are ideal for high-mileage drivers who regularly travel long distances and can handle higher maintenance costs. EVs, with their lower running costs and environmental benefits, are the most economical choice for most buyers who can charge at home, making them increasingly attractive as battery technology and charging infrastructure improve. If you’re weighing EV vs petrol in the used market, Spinny lets you compare cars side by side, and every car goes through a 200-point inspection and comes with Fixed Price Assurance.
Summary
Choosing between a petrol, diesel or electric car comes down to more than the price on the window sticker, and the total cost of ownership tells the real story. Using the Tata Nexon as an example, the 30 kWh Nexon EV now costs only slightly more to buy than a comparable petrol or diesel, yet runs at about Rs 0.74 per km when charged at home against about Rs 5.94 for petrol, making it the cheapest option over five years at every distance we tested. If you are weighing a new EV against a used petrol car, the used car usually wins on total cost if you drive less than about 1,450 km a month, while the EV pulls ahead if you drive more and can charge at home. Spinny makes the used side of that decision easier, with every car going through a 200-point inspection and coming with Fixed Price Assurance. Knowing how far you drive and where you will charge is the simplest way to pick the car that saves you the most.
FAQs about Petrol, Diesel and Electric cars
Q. Which of the three has the most mileage – petrol cars, diesel cars or electric cars?
Diesel cars offer the highest mileage and range on a full tank, followed by petrol cars. Electric cars have a shorter range per charge, but their much lower cost per kilometre allows you to drive more for the same money.
Q. How does the initial purchase cost compare across petrol, diesel and electric vehicles?
EVs usually cost the most to purchase initially owing to the high cost of the battery itself. They’re followed by diesel cars and lastly, petrol cars, which are generally the cheapest. With the 2025 GST changes, the gap between EVs and diesel cars has narrowed considerably.
Q. What is the range of electric cars, compared to gas and diesel cars?
Most mass-market EVs in India claim a range of about 300–500 km on a full charge, whereas petrol and diesel cars can travel 600–1,000 km on a full tank.
Q. Which car type is the best for city driving – petrol, diesel or electric?
Since EVs produce no tailpipe emissions, operate quietly, and accelerate quickly, they are an ideal vehicle for city driving, especially if you can charge at home. Because of their reasonable fuel efficiency and lower starting cost, petrol cars are also a good option for city driving.
Q. How reliable are electric cars compared to petrol or diesel cars?
Because they have fewer moving parts, EVs generally need less routine maintenance and have fewer components that can wear out. The battery is the most expensive part, so check its warranty terms and, on a used EV, its health report.
Q. New electric car vs a used petrol car: which has the lower total cost in India?
It depends on how much you drive. In our example, a used Nexon petrol automatic works out cheaper over five years if you drive less than about 1,450 km a month, thanks to its much lower purchase price. If you drive more than that and can charge at home, a new Nexon EV’s lower running cost makes it the cheaper option overall.
Q. How much does it cost to run an electric car compared to a petrol car per km?
Charging at home at Rs 8 per unit, a Nexon EV costs about Rs 0.74 per km to run, while a Nexon petrol costs about Rs 5.94 per km at Delhi’s petrol price of Rs 102.12 per litre. Public fast charging costs more per unit, so the electric car cost per km goes up if you rely on it.





